Visit DOTmed at RSNA, North Hall B, Booth #6608 -- Ask about Clean Sweep Equipment Auctions

Current Location:
> This Story

Log in or Register to rate this News Story
Forward Printable StoryPrint Comment

Never Miss a Story

Sign up for email alerts


More Industry Headlines

Panel calls for radiologists to 'take a seat at the table' in shaping new payment model RSNA 2015

RSNA: Raising the bar on breast tomosynthesis The benefits of C-View software for improving the new standard in breast imaging

RSNA: FUJIFILM announces two major new DR innovations World's first long-length DR detector and FDR Visionary Suite

Philips launches IntelliSpace Portal 8.0 platform at RSNA More than 68 clinical applications for visualizing CT, MR, ultrasound, mammo, and more

New scattered X-ray method delivers a whole new view of your tooth Measuring structures as small as a billionth of a meter

Breast MR after mammography may catch additional aggressive cancers How clinically significant are multicentric cancers?

Bilingual patients have better cognitive function after stroke But it may not apply to all bilingual people

Will the future hold compact, tunable X-ray devices made of graphene? May reduce radiation dose and cost associated with current X-ray devices

Dell announces entry into health care monitor market New device is designed to meet IEC 60601-1 standard

Canadian hospital clerk who sold maternity records fined $27,000 — hospital facing $308.4 million suit From 1995 to 2014 she sold at least 14,450 records

Medical device manufacturers still seek 'clarity' on device tax for refurbished equipment, donations

by Brendon Nafziger , DOTmed News Associate Editor
The controversial 2.3 percent excise tax on medical device sales has already been in effect for a few months, but it's still causing confusion among manufacturers, a lobbyist group said.

In comments sent to the Internal Revenue Service last week, AdvaMed, a trade group, said they still lacked "clarity" on some issues, such as whether repaired or refurbished equipment were truly exempt from the tax. The group also wants to make sure that devices donated to doctors traveling on medical missions or providing disaster relief aren't taxed.

Story Continues Below Advertisement

Solve the service puzzle with Consensys

We believe the right person to decide how best to service your diagnostic imaging equipment is you. Our reputation is built on providing high quality & reliable service to our customers. MRI | CT | Ultrasound | Mammography

AdvaMed's letter comes at the close of the comment period for the IRS' final rules on the tax, which the agency released along with guidance for manufacturers in early December only a few weeks before the tax took effect on Jan. 1.

"It's a very challenging environment," Chris White, AdvaMed's general counsel and executive vice president, told DOTmed News. "To implement this tax has been extremely burdensome to our companies."

Murky legal precedent

Although federal attorneys had previously indicated in talks with IAMERS, a trade group for imaging equipment resellers, that most refurbished equipment would not be subject to the tax, AdvaMed said the status of repaired, modified or refurbished devices is still ultimately murky because of the legal history of excise taxes.

"Legally the interpretation of the medical device excise tax relies not just on specific guidance, but also all of those earlier decades of tax court decisions and other regulations in the excise tax area," White said. "Upon reflection and review of that body of precedent, it was our view that there wasn't sufficient clarity on how refurbishment and repairing would be treated under the law."

Because of that, the group is asking the IRS to do one of two things. Under one proposal, the IRS would spell out that the tax would only apply to new components separately listed with the Food and Drug Administration. (The tax itself only applies to medical devices listed with the FDA.)

White indicated this would most likely apply to capital equipment. Although he wouldn't name a specific category it would apply to, he said there could be a "component or element that needs to be repaired or refurbished, and to the extent that component is replaced and itself qualifies as a separately listed medical device, the tax would apply to the value of that component."

"This is a fair resolution. It avoids double taxation," he added.

The second solution would be what AdvaMed calls a "bright line safe harbor". In this proposal, the group wants the IRS to not tax repairs or modifications that represent less than, say, 75 percent of the value of the device. AdvaMed said there's precedent for such exemptions in truck remanufacturing, where truck and tractor bodies are also subject to a first-sale excise tax.

Medical missions

AdvaMed is also asking the IRS not to tax devices donated to doctors going on medical missions or disaster relief trips. White said in the IRS guidance for charitable exemptions, only specified entities — largely tax-exempt organizations, such as non-profits — appear to be eligible for the exemption, not private individuals.

"However, it's a bona fide charitable purpose," White said. "A company shouldn't be taxed for providing (a device) for a hurricane site or disaster area."

Device manufacturers had other requests, too. They're asking the IRS to reduce their paperwork burden by allowing those buying equipment for export or remanufacture to estimate total quarterly orders rather than provide information for each article. And they also want equipment loaned or given to doctors merely for demonstrations, and not for patient use, not to be subject to the tax.

White said they had no timeline on when they expect a response from the IRS.


Interested in Medical Industry News? Subscribe to DOTmed's weekly news email and always be informed. Click here, it takes just 30 seconds.

You Must Be Logged In To Post A Comment

Increase Your
Brand Awareness
Auctions + Private Sales
Get The
Best Price
Buy Equipment/Parts
Find The
Lowest Price
Daily News
Read The
Latest News
Browse All
DOTmed Users
Ethics on DOTmed
View Our
Ethics Program
Gold Parts Vendor Program
Receive PH
Gold Service Dealer Program
Receive RFP/PS
Healthcare Providers
See all
HCP Tools
A Job
Parts Hunter +EasyPay
Get Parts
Recently Certified
View Recently
Certified Users
Recently Rated
View Recently
Certified Users
Rental Central
Rent Equipment
For Less
Sell Equipment/Parts
Get The
Most Money
Service Technicians Forum
Find Help
And Advice
Simple RFP
Get Equipment
Virtual Trade Show
Find Service
For Equipment
Access and use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions of our LEGAL NOTICE & PRIVACY NOTICE
Property of and Proprietary to DOTmed.com, Inc. Copyright ©2001-2015 DOTmed.com, Inc.