dismiss

Get a Free 3-Day Pass to AAMI 2014 in Philadelphia, May 31-June 2 -- Visit DOTmed, Booth 231

SEARCH

Current Location: DOTmed News > Industry Headlines > This Story


Log in or Register to rate this News Story
Forward Printable StoryPrint Send us your Comments

 

More Industry Headlines

FDA clears new CT system from Siemens Ideal for challenging cases.

FDA OKs Shimadzu's new R/F system For a wide variety of exams.

Gov. Jan Brewer signs breast density law Arizona becomes the latest state with inform legislation.

CT can detect arterial plaque for diabetics CCTA is a welcome development.

Goggles that illuminate cancer cells Could they reduce second surgeries?

Philips suspends CT and PET/CT production at Ohio facility Setback for customers and the company.

Varian's seven year patent dispute comes to an end Company will pay about $35 million.

FDA OKs GE's new CT scanner Ideal for challenging cases.

MRI technique can help treat concussion patients Measures white brain matter damage.

What's the big-picture impact of HIT on health care? Q&A with thought leader Bipin Thomas.

Can neuroscience
aid the legal system?

Brain Imaging and Criminal Law

by Astrid Fiano , DOTmed News Writer
MacArthur Law and Neuroscience Project (LNP) out of the University of California, Santa Barbara, is an organization devoting serious research to the use of brain imaging in criminal law. Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, PhD, Co-Director of the LNP and Professor of Philosophy and Legal Studies at Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH, spoke to DOTmed about the goals of the Project and its research topics.

Prof. Sinnott-Armstrong explained that the project developed from the MacArthur Foundation seeking useful projects to pursue. Dr. Robert Sapolsky, Professor of Neurology and Neurological Sciences, at Stanford University, suggested that the criminal justice system was in need of reform, and neuroscience could help. The Foundation approached Professor Sinnott-Armstrong, along with Art Singer, and they put together an advisory board. Dr. Michael Gazzaniga, of the University of California, Santa Barbara (future Director of the Project), and Stephen Morse, Professor of Psychology and Law in Psychiatry from the University of Pennsylvania Law School (future Legal Director of the Project) were on the advisory board, and crucial to the successful proposal to the Foundation and inception of the project. The participants were motivated in part to use "good" neuroscience to aid the legal system and in part to avoid the influence of "bad" neuroscience in the courtroom.

Story Continues Below Advertisement

Cios Alpha - a new generation of Mobile C-arm Technology

With Cios Alpha Siemens brings to life a vision of a mobile C-arm that optimizes your surgical team's confidence, efficiency and operational workflow



Good vs. Bad

What can be considered a "bad" use of neuroscience? Professor Sinnott-Armstrong points out a recent case in India. A process involving EEGs, called the Brain Electrical Oscillations Signature test (BEOS) was developed by Champadi Raman Mukundan, an Indian neuroscientist and former director of the clinical psychology department of the National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences in Bangalore. The results of the process were used in court for a murder case in Pune, India. According to the International Herald-Tribune, the judge cited the scan as proof the defendant's brain held guilty knowledge concerning the crime. The defendant was sentenced to life in prison. However, current brain state and imaging technology does not yet appear to function at the level of reliability most legal systems demand.

Using inferences from neuroscience for legal conclusions raises a question at every step, Professor Sinnott-Armstrong points out. As an example, an imaging procedure might be good to detect a structural abnormality within the brain, such as a tumor, but how relevant is the procedure to a legal situation--what does it have to do with criminal responsibility? In other words, can we infer from the brain scan that the person couldn't control his or her actions due to that tumor?

Continue reading Brain Imaging and Criminal Law...
  Pages: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - ... >>

Interested in Medical Industry News? Subscribe to DOTmed's weekly news email and always be informed. Click here, it takes just 30 seconds.
Access and use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions of our LEGAL NOTICE & PRIVACY NOTICE
Property of and Proprietary to DOTmed.com, Inc. Copyright ©2001-2014 DOTmed.com, Inc.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED