Newly uncovered report suggests Huntington Memorial patient deaths linked to superbug outbreak

May 06, 2016
by Thomas Dworetzky, Contributing Reporter
Early this year, Olympus recalled one of its duodenoscopes, Model TJF-Q180V, which had been linked to a superbug outbreak at UCLA Ronald Reagan Medical Center. Now a second model of its duodenoscope has been implicated in the deaths last year of three Huntington Memorial Hospital hospital patients.

A newly surfaced FDA report has suggested that an older Olympus scope used since 2002 at Huntington, Model TJF-160F, may have also caused fatalities last year, according to the Los Angeles Times.

An investigation was launched last August by The Pasadena Public Health Department.

In a statement at the time, Steve Ralph, President and CEO of Huntington Memorial, announced that the devices had been quarantined, that federal investigators were looking into the situation and that “elective surgeries were temporarily halted Monday evening and resumed Tuesday," according to Pasadena Now.

The hospital on Thursday would not confirm the deaths or disclose how many patients may have been infected. But Olympus said the hospital reported three patients died in connection to the outbreak, according to a filing with the FDA.

This week the hospitals chief medical officer Paula Verette said that an outreach was started to patients to contact everyone "who underwent a procedure using an Olympus scope in the preceding months,” and that the effort continues to monitor their health status, according to the online news service.

While investigators would not discuss the situation at Huntington, several nurses told Pasadena Now that they had found errors with surgical trays that made them "not sterile."

“When they encountered the same situation in three trays, the auditors ordered that the entire inventory of trays had to be taken down and reprocessed,” Tina Gold, a former Huntington Hospital OR nurse alleged to PN. She also claimed to be in regular contact with former colleagues. “This massive undertaking led to the cancellation of 38 elective [surgery] cases.”

Medical Safety Expert Lawrence Muscarella told the Pasadena Star News he uncovered the deaths by tracking FDA “adverse event” reports, of which there have been almost 30 involving scopes, reported by Olympus since 2014. Why the Huntington hospital did not publicly share test results for the devices, nor state the number of patients exposed, mystifies him.

“Hospital care is about integrity, compassion and honesty — not silence,” Muscarella told the publication.

When asked by the paper about the issue, Pasadena Public Health officials declined to comment as the investigation is still open.

“Part of the investigation includes looking into any fatalities that may have occurred," stated Pasadena spokesperson William Boyer.

The hospital spokesperson also declined to comment, other than to point to Verette's earlier statement.

It remains unclear just how many people may have been affected by the outbreak at Huntington hospital.

“The allegation is that Olympus knew that the models could not be disinfected,” said Peter Kaufman, a lawyer for three patients suing Olympus after getting sick following procedures with the older scopes at Huntington. Two of these people died.

“I’ve been doing this for 15 years and for whatever reason, underreporting of adverse events related to drugs and medical devices continues to be a problem that puts patients at risk,” he told the Star, adding, “I think a lot of it has to do with the way manufacturers market and interact with physicians and hospitals. It’s a market-driven endeavor. It seems like safety is one of the first casualties.”