A total of 21 patients completed both treatments and lived, on average, five months longer without their disease progressing any further. In two patients (9.5%), tumors outside the treated area shrank by 30% or more and stayed that way for more than a year. Ten patients (47.6%) experienced disease stabilization (tumors neither grew nor shrank) following the addition of SBRT.

“We weren’t surprised to see that some patients had tumors shrink outside the field of radiation,” said Dr. Campbell, who added that the research team really wanted to learn more about what was happening in the immune systems of those patients. “There’s been a lot of interest in how radiation can stimulate the immune system. We wanted to learn all we could from our very best responders.”


A closer analysis of the peripheral blood cells in patients whose tumors shrank or did not grow suggested that T cells played an important role in the immune system response, said Dr. Campbell. “We found that there were two things that correlated with patients living longer without their disease progressing,” she said. “Those two things were T cells infiltrating the tumor before immunotherapy was given, and the presence of immune-related side effects at any time during the course of treatment, such as inflammation of the lung or inflammation of the GI tract. Patients who experienced these side effects lived a longer period of time before the disease progressed.”

Dr. Campbell and her team were able to identify two different types of T cells performing important functions in fighting the tumors. In patients who responded well to the combination therapy, they found both CD8 T cells, which can kill cancer cells directly, and CD4 T cells, which help the immune system organize its response to threats such as cancer. “We saw different proportions of these cells in our good responders versus our bad responders,” she said, “as well as different activation statuses. In people who responded well to the combination therapy, we saw a population of CD8 T cells that looked more excited, and in those with poor responses, we saw a population of CD4 T cells with inhibitory markers. The bigger picture here is that there are signatures in the peripheral blood that are promising avenues for future identification of people who will respond well to SBRT combined with immunotherapy.”

The next step, she said, will be to validate these findings in a larger population.

“We are starting to see that the combination of immunotherapy and radiation is safe and there are some hints that for certain patients, radiation might be an important option when immunotherapy no longer curbs disease progression,” said Dr. Campbell. “Our study lays the groundwork for a phase III randomized trial, which is the gold standard for changing guidelines and clinical practice.”

Rad Oncology Homepage