DOTmed Home MRI Oncology Ultrasound Molecular Imaging X-Ray Cardiology Health IT Business Affairs
News Home Parts & Service Operating Room CT Women's Health Proton Therapy Endoscopy HTMs Mobile Imaging
SEARCH
Current Location:
>
> This Story

starstarstarstarempty star (1)
Log in or Register to rate this News Story
Forward Printable StoryPrint Send us your Comments

 

 

More Industry Headlines

IMAGE Information Systems releases iQ VIEW PRO 3.1 Can identify relevant priors in 1-2 seconds in PACS of more than one million studies

Trump administration halts tariff proposal on Chinese imports... for now The 25 percent tariffs get placed on the back burner

Is low cost Proton-to-Carbon Heavy Ion radiotherapy coming soon? Best Particle Therapy plans to bring smaller footprint system to market in two to three years

'Fake Cerner' MR fraud conspirator pleads guilty, has fatal seizure same day Suresh Mitta passed away within hours of going into custody

Coalition urges CMS clarification on low dose CT guidance Coverage regularly excluded when performed at independent imaging facilities

Gaining the experience advantage In the digital economy, value needs to be evaluated through the eyes of the customer

New algorithm predicts impact of heart transplants on survival in heart failure patients Acquires information based on 53 data points to predict rate and length of survival

Change Healthcare unveils InterQual 2018 Supports decision-making by providing updated and enhanced clinical criteria

NHS surgeons use 3D printing to perform lifesaving kidney transplant Stratasys technology used to plan operation on two-year-old boy

MRI Interventions and Voyager Therapeutics partner on Parkinson's therapy Bringing real-time MR guidance to minimally-invasive neurosurgical devices

Report gives good marks to European device regulations

by Brendon Nafziger , DOTmed News Associate Editor
An industry-funded report argues that the medical device regulations in Europe are as safe as in the United States, even though the European system is thought to be much faster.

The report, released Friday, comes as the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and European regulators both mull profound changes to the way medical devices get brought to market.

Story Continues Below Advertisement

OR Tables, Treatment/GYN/Uro Chairs, Transport Stretchers, Hospital/ICU Bed

iMS combines the superior service of Oakworks Medical and advanced manufacturing technology of FAMED Medical Solutions. The goal of iMS, "Connecting Art and Medical Science" goes way beyond product with exceptional CareLink service. Contact us today!



According to the report, prepared by The Boston Consulting Group for AdvaMed, a U.S. device lobby, the average number of serious recalls are about 21 per year in both Europe and America.

"We found the same number of recalls, even though the belief is there are more devices out in Europe," Simon Goodall, Boston's partner and managing director, told reporters in a call.

Although AdvaMed did not present hard data, it said devices were often approved in Europe "years" before they reached the United States, partly because of the increasingly tough U.S. regulatory stance.

But safety advocates disputed the findings of the report, arguing that it was "highly biased." The advocates also said the study was weakened by flawed assumptions, and that much of its methodology remains obscure.

"[S]uch a report would never successfully pass through a rigorous peer-review process," Dr. Sidney Wolfe and Dr. Michael Carome, who head the health research division of Public Citizen, a public watchdog group founded by Ralph Nader, said in a statement e-mailed to DOTmed News.

Crossing the pond

Part of the trouble in seeing whether the European system is as safe as America's is the two systems are strikingly different.

In the United States, approval and regulation of devices -- including the issuing of recalls and safety alerts -- all pass through the FDA, a federal agency. But in the European Union, the approvals are handled by 74 for-profit companies called Notified Bodies, which are certified by member countries, AdvaMed said.

Thus, for Europe, unlike the United States, there's no central database to find recall alerts. Instead, Field Safety Notices, roughly, though not always, the European equivalent of a recall notice, are tacked up on the public websites of many countries. Countries also have to file major safety issues in reports known as National Competent Authority Reports, which are gathered by the European Commission.

To complicate matters, the FSNs don't match up with the FDA's three-tiered recall system, which ranks recalls based on how much of a risk the device presents to the public.

The report tried to tackle these discrepancies by collecting FSNs posted on public websites by Germany, Ireland, Switzerland, France and the United Kingdom, the five countries representing the bulk of serious safety reports. It then checked these off against the major safety reports, the NCARs, gathered by the EC. (In the UK, these are called MDAs.) These results were then coded independently by two reviewers in terms of the severity of the recalls, and then compared with two earlier studies of the safety of U.S. devices.
  Pages: 1 - 2 >>

Related:


Advertise
Increase Your
Brand Awareness
Auctions + Private Sales
Get The
Best Price
Buy Equipment/Parts
Find The
Lowest Price
Daily News
Read The
Latest News
Directory
Browse All
DOTmed Users
Ethics on DOTmed
View Our
Ethics Program
Gold Parts Vendor Program
Receive PH
Requests
Gold Service Dealer Program
Receive RFP/PS
Requests
Healthcare Providers
See all
HCP Tools
Jobs/Training
Find/Fill
A Job
Parts Hunter +EasyPay
Get Parts
Quotes
Recently Certified
View Recently
Certified Users
Recently Rated
View Recently
Certified Users
Rental Central
Rent Equipment
For Less
Sell Equipment/Parts
Get The
Most Money
Service Technicians Forum
Find Help
And Advice
Simple RFP
Get Equipment
Quotes
Virtual Trade Show
Find Service
For Equipment
Access and use of this site is subject to the terms and conditions of our LEGAL NOTICE & PRIVACY NOTICE
Property of and Proprietary to DOTmed.com, Inc. Copyright ©2001-2018 DOTmed.com, Inc.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED