Study calls for greater discussion of cost in breast cancer surgery decisions
Current Location:
> This Story

Log in or Register to rate this News Story
Forward Printable StoryPrint Comment




Operating Room Homepage

VR produces better surgeons than traditional training Study shows 230 percent improvement in overall surgical performance

OR products and services market expected to reach $7.04 billion by 2022 Frost & Sullivan analysis looks at US and EU5 hospital markets

Mount Sinai surgeons first in NY to perform minimally-invasive heart bypass surgery Only for highly-skilled surgeons for now

MR and ultrasound biopsies combined can detect prostate cancers, says study Detect up to 33 percent more tumors together

One-third of breast cancer patients not aware of minimal scarring surgery Remote incisions can avert physical and psychological impacts of scarring

Philips teams with Medtronic on cryoablation treatment for atrial fibrillation Will form an integrated solution for cryoablation

Court denies Hologic's attempt to halt sale of Minerva's ablation solution Follows a drawn out case over patent infringement

Using comic illustrations to support patient understanding of cardiac catheterization Making patients more satisfied, less anxious and more informed

Improving surgical outcomes by imaging head and neck tumors in real time Researchers use tech developed by Perimeter Medical Imaging

Medical community finds ways to make TAVR safer for at-risk patients Improving outcomes with special procedures

Nearly one in three women
consider cost to play a role in
their breast cancer surgical

Study calls for greater discussion of cost in breast cancer surgery decisions

by John R. Fischer , Staff Reporter
Surgeons may be wise to discuss with women the costs of different types of surgical procedures for breast cancer in more detail.

That’s what a new study by the Duke Cancer Institute asserts, based on its finding that nearly a third of women report cost as a factor in their choice of surgery.

Story Continues Below Advertisement

New & Refurbished C-Arm Systems. Call 702.384.0085 Today!

KenQuest provides all major brands of surgical c-arms (new and refurbished) and carries a large inventory for purchase or rent. With over 20 years in the medical equipment business we can help you fulfill your equipment needs

“Prior research, including our own, suggests that several barriers exist to cost communication within breast cancer surgeons, including lack of knowledge, perceived inability to help patients with the high costs of cancer treatment, and some concern that cost discussions may negatively impact the care that patients receive. Additionally, the actual costs of treatment are difficult to assess," lead author Dr. Rachel Greenup, a surgeon at Duke Cancer Institute, told HCB News. "Costs of cancer treatment, however, were influential on decisions for breast cancer surgery, even among insured and relatively advantaged women.”

Though similar in outcomes, surgical approaches can differ in cost. Surgeons often discuss emotional and physical-side effects but seldom the price of operations, which include breast conserving surgery (lumpectomy with radiation), mastectomy, and double mastectomy with or without breast reconstruction.

Researchers in the study provided an electronic survey to more than 600 women with stage 0-III breast cancer, asking them about their choice of surgery. Participants were substantially more affluent than the U.S. average, with 90 percent white, 70 percent enrolled in private insurance, 25 percent on Medicare, 78 percent college educated, and 56 percent with household incomes above $74,000 a year.

Such advantages, however, did not negate cost as a factor for many, with 43 percent reporting that they considered costs when making breast cancer treatment decisions. Nearly a third said it played a role in their choice of surgery, and women with household incomes under $45,000 a year said cost was more important than keeping their breasts or their appearance.

In addition, 35 percent of respondents, overall, reported their cancer treatment as a cause of financial burden, while 78 percent never discussed costs with their cancer team. Among even those with the highest incomes, 65 percent were fiscally unprepared for the cost of their procedure. Of all choices, double mastectomies were associated with higher patient-reported debt and financial hardship.

“Women should be open to inquiring about cancer treatment costs if they have concerns about affording their cancer care," said Greenup. "Institutionally and nationally there are resources that can help offload cancer-related financial burden for our patients. Evolving research suggests that the simple act of cost discussions may lead to cost-reducing strategies as well.”

Participants were members of the Army of Women, a national coalition of breast cancer survivors and activists, and the Sisters Network of North Carolina, an African-American breast cancer survivors’ group.

The findings were published in the Journal of Oncology Practice.

Operating Room Homepage

You Must Be Logged In To Post A Comment